Gaddis Chapter 3

Chapter 3: Command Versus Spontaneity:

Section 1: Marxism

-B. Disraeli writes Sybil about the classes, industrial revolution. Warns that countries exploiting people for economy will be in trouble. Marx agrees.

-Marxism makes poor happy, rich scared, and governments in between.

-Wilson sees problems with military fighting Germany and other fighting with Bolsheviks in 1917/1918.

Section 2: Marxism-Leninism

-Marx is vague, Lenin gets it done.

-End of WWII, Wilson would look like a failed idealist, compromises too much.

-End of WWII, Lenin would look like a successful realist.

-Marxism-Leninism is very popular in Europe. Americans self-doubt.

Section 3: Reviewing Obvious Things

-Cold War changed everything.

-Pearl Harbor affects security, Wilson becomes relevant.

-Everyone was initially allies, stuff changed, duh.

Section 4: More Obvious Things

-Ideologies are different. Stalin and Lenin both were horrible to their country.

-Germans occupying USSR were really bad too.

-Marx is a lot like Stalin.

Section 5: Goals of the US

-No one ever planned how to use capitalism to stop communism.

-US wants military stuff to be kept away from some other countries.

-Function of government – facilitate freedom. (Marshall Plan)

-US was the only economically capable country to attack SU.

Section 6: Stalin/Beria/Plotting

-Maybe Stalin was the problem.

-Beria stops purges, tries to close Korean War, wants to fix up Germany.

-West Germany made Stalin angry: communism can’t go there naturally, so he forms East Germany.

-That all goes badly. Beria tries to crush East German uprising, thrown in jail.

Section 7: Khrushchev

-Khrushchev tracks and mocks Stalin’s crimes (communists not used to admitting mistakes, Bierut dies, freaks out all other communists, really dumb idea).

-Gets rid of Rakosi. Re-enters Hungary, kills a lot of people.

Section 8: China & Khrushchev

-China helps Khrushchev suppress Hungarian uprising.

-Mao not consulted about Khrushchev’s insane speech against Stalin.

-Mao differs in action, doesn’t want to reform peasants as much.

-Mao has a Great Leap Forward, kills people.

Section 9: The Wall

-Rest of world is not aware of what is going on.

-Everyone is vulnerable, scared, etc.

-East Germans riot, leave. They built a giant wall, August 1961, with other precautions. NO ONE CAN LEAVE!

Section 10:

-Capitalism succeeding, outside of wall.

-No one knows what to do about problems.

-Marxism & successors didn’t do too well with actual humans.

Gaddis Chapters 1 & 2

Chapter 1: The Return of Fear

Section 1: Different & the Same

-US and SU based in revolution (American Revolution & Bolshevik Revolution)

-Both very different (US did multiple wars at once, SU did one war at a time)

-Soviet deaths = 90x Americans dead

-Stalin is the only one in a certain, confirmed position and country

Section 2: What Stalin Wants

-Stalin in charge, wants security, believes SU should get majority of post-war things (territories, money, punishing Germany)

-Marxist-Leninist ideologies influence Stalin, thinks depression/crisis will return post-WWII, everyone will need the SU, so the US should give the SU lots of money

-Stalin underestimates GB constantly

-Does not want to restore balance of power, but rule absolutely over Europe

Section 3: What the US Wants

-US cannot be separate from the world and still be a model for the world, wants global influence

-US is no longer isolationist during WWI, WWII. This concerns many Americans

-FDR pushing for involvement in world politics (difficult), 4 priorities (keep allies GB SU and China, get cooperation for postwar settlements, make that settlement have collective security with power, and the settlement would be “sellable” to the US)

-GB wants to influence US

Section 4: Sharing & Splitting Powers

-Separate peace would make second front slowly, politically important

-SU/GB agree that Stalin has influence, FDR feels left out, protests

-Everyone has spheres of influence that they want; Poland is angry and imposed on by Stalin

-Germany occupied mostly by GB, France, and US. Stalin is aggressive, has plans. Germans prefer Anglo-American control over SU control

-Atomic bombs make SU-US not trusting, spying on each other, ruins balance

Section 5: Plotting

-US/SU both sending telegrams from ambassadors to home country, awkward meetings later

-Truman Doctrine/Marshall Plan: assisting Greece/Turkey with military/economy versus European Recovery Program and a plan for a great wall. Stalin gets tricked, builds wall

-Stalin makes Cominform, SU loses some allies, blockades Berlin, backfires

-Stalin lifts blockade in May 1949

Section 6: Fears & Spies

-US expects to rule with atomic bombs, SU makes their own which concerns the US

-Truman tells US to super-produce atomic bombs

-Mao forms People’s Republic of China, surprises US and SU. Mao wants to ally with SU, feels betrayed by US

-GB and US find spies in State Department and Manhattan Project, McCarthy scares everyone

Section 7: Korea

-Korea occupied by SU/US, part of Japanese empire previously, SU/US withdraw

-US denies support to S. Korea, N. Korea’s ruler Kim Il-sung plots, wants SU to help unify

-Stalin tells Kim Il-sung to go invade S. Korea, impacts US stationed nearby

-US and S. Korea retreat, Stalin gives up.

Section 8:

-Winning WWII didn’t make anyone feel better

-Kennan (containment founder) tells students that everyone has totalitarianism in them

-Kennan says that force is a means to and end, A & H bombs aren’t like that

Chapter 1: Deathboats & Lifeboats

Section 1: History of War

­-Atomic bombs are unique and concerning. War isn’t new, but this weaponry is

-War impacts empires mostly. Bombs made to be used if functioning, only used twice for 20th century

Section 2: All About Bombs

-Truman thinks atomic bombs are really bad. Political leaders usually give military the choice about weapons and fighting, Truman does too.

-Post-bombings, he says no more, civilian agency, not military, controls bombs. Proposes to give United Nations all technology in 1946.

Section 3: Stalin’s Bomb

-Pentagon concerned by amount of Red Army troops in Europe, few available to US

-Truman hopes Stalin recognizes power of atomic bombs, moderates self. Stalin makes program to build a Soviet bomb, fearful

-Everyone wants to hide fears, threaten other countries

-Soviets get atomic bomb in August 1949

Section 4: What to Do with Korea

-Truman & administration concerned about Chinese troops chasing US, S. Koreans

-No one wants to use atomic bombs in Korea or China, although possible, no one wants to expand war even more

-Stalin is vague. He authorized/began Korean War and acknowledges likeliness of a military stalemate. No direct military confrontations for years about Korea.

Section 5: Super-Bombs

-US scientists tell Truman about potential for thermonuclear or super-bomb. Everyone opposes the “psychologically necessary” weapons

-Soviets develop super-bomb

-Everyone tests bombs on birds, not humans

Section 6: Super-Bombs, Part 2

-Truman leaves office, Stalin dies. Eisenhower in charge.

-Super-bombs are tested (BRAVO), 750x the Hiroshima bombing, spreads everywhere

-Churchill in charge again, opposing Malenkov, Malenkov demoted, Churchill steps down in 1955

Section 7: Eisenhower

-Eisenhower makes depressing comments, doesn’t want to use atomic weapons often

-Eisenhower plans only for total war

Section 8: Khrushchev

-SU tested first thermonuclear bomb in late 1955. 1.5 years later, they launch intercontinental ballistic missile, launches Sputnik a few months later

-Khrushchev is in charge, learns about nuclear weapons, and doesn’t want to use them

-Khrushchev says he is mass-producing bombs, later admits to exaggerating. Repeatedly threatens US with nuclear attack, not actually possible for him. Wants to visit US

-Visits in later 1959, wants to go to Disneyland, gets in fights

Section 9: Planes & Lies

-New US spy plane tests in 1956, takes photos of Soviet forces, proves that they are limited

-Khrushchev teaches son about fighting the US

-Khrushchev meets with Eisenhower in Paris, wants to be annoying to everyone

-Kennedy is waiting, calls out Khrushchev about lies, Khrushchev tests big-bomb

Section 10: Castro

-Castro is trying to have a revolution, in trouble, Khrushchev has missiles but no plans

-Khrushchev is committed to Castro emotionally

-Cuban missile crisis makes everyone fearful

Section 11: Changes

-Kennedy in charge, wants to get rid of nuclear war. Eisenhower left minimal war plans, would have needed to use all nuclear bombs simultaneously, against every country.

-McNamara makes new plan, some problems with his strategy. Wants to attack only military, no cities, must get Khrushchev to operate similarly. Not likely

-1963: Limited Test Ban Treaty abolishes nuclear tests in atmosphere

-1972: Anti-Ballistic Missile Treaty abolishes defenses against long-range missiles

-Fear of war is more important than anything

Section 12: Life of Pi

-Life of Pi is a possible Cold War story